After eating a delicious but unexpectedly spicy dinner at Mama Ricotta’s, I needed something to cool me down fast and Curtis knew exactly what that was… Ice cream!
So we headed down to the Elizabeth Creamery.
It’s a very quaint little old fashioned ice cream shop on Elizabeth Street. There however.. was not a nice woman named Elizabeth inside to great us like I was expecting, but instead there was a very friendly Asian man who hand makes all 48 flavors offered at the Elizabeth Creamery. The decision was torturous but eventually we decided on 1 scoop of Mint Oreo and 1 scoop of Butterfinger.
Both flavors were perfectly smooth and creamy and exactly what I was looking for. The mint oreo was the better of the two flavors and taste a lot like mint chocolate chip but without the chocolate chips. Before we left we sampled a curiously named flavor… it was called “Smurf”. Our best description was ice cream mixed with medicine mixed with marshmallows… not nearly our favorite.